Audio file duration - 6:56
https://speechify.app.link/e/OcEXeWmZbZb

The Congressional Gold Medal is the highest civilian honor Congress can bestow, and past recipients include allied veteran groups such as Filipino World War II veterans and other distinguished contributors to U.S. history.

Debate over Historical Representation

First hand accounts and observations have been made and recorded questioning the language in this bill which inaccuratly attributes the Hmong claiming they interupted the Ho Chi Minh Trail, when in fact they were concentrated in a different military region and helped disrupt other supply lines which could not be confused with the vast Ho Chi Minh Trail System. This has prompted letters and discussions about whether the historical record is being fully respected in the bill's text.

Many members of Asian American and Southeast Asian communities including United States and allied Southeast Asian Veterans feel that the focus on the Hmong in federal and state honors, while important, sometimes overshadows or complicates broader recognition for other Southeast Asian groups who also experienced war related trauma and service. This dynamic is similar to other debates on state or local honors such as the redefinition of a Veteran which awarded Hmong veterans state benifits by redefining the word Veteran and createing a new category of a veteran in Minnesota Law in 2025.
 ( https://www.cavwv.org/veteran-defined.html ). The Hmong have recieved Federal recognition and burial in National Cemeteries in 2018. ( https://www.cavwv.org/hmong-burial-controversy.html ) Monument installations in Arlington National Cemetery in Virginia and Fort Snelling National Cemetery in Minnesota which acompany numerous other state and local recognitions including other monuments and Commemoration Days. Many other Southeast Asian veteran communities of different ethnicities who fought along side the United States during the Vietnam War and the Secret War in Southeast Asia see this as elevating one group's history without inclusivity and propper context.

Why it matters

For many Hmong Americans, especially, aging veterans they perceive this recognition as about national acknowledgment and historical justice for decades of service. From their point of view they perceive that they have received relatively little federal honor compared to other allied groups.​ This unfortunely is an unfounded claim as the Hmong in fact have gained more federal, state and local honors than many other Southeast Asian veteran communities.

The Legislation

Senate File 3271
House File 2427
Picture
Senator Amy Kloburchar [MN]
Picture
Senator Gary Peters [MI]
Picture
Representative Burgess Owens [UT]
Picture
Representative Glenn Grothman [WI]
        Senate File 3271 was introduced by Senator Amy Kloburchar and Senator Gary Peters in the United States Senate with six cosponsors on November 9, 2023. 
        House Resolution 2427 was introduced by Representatives Burgess Owens and Glenn Grothman in the United States House of Representatives with forty nine cosponsors on March 30, 2023.

      The error made and ensuing controversy brewing.

       With the abundance of resources given to our elected officials in crafting laws in Washington D.C., unfortunately yet another law has been introduced  gathering cosponsorships in the United States Congress. Senate File. 3271 has proven to be controversial in that our Veteran Allies and Southeast Asian Communities have identified a glaring error within the bills language, (S.3271, page 2, lines 5-6), clearly states " Interrupted the Ho-Chi-Min(h) Supply Trail".   This unfortunate mistake has generated several letters to the Congressmen who introduced and cosponsored the legislation by those allies that actually did the service sited in the bill, "interrupt the Ho Chi Minh Trail". The Bill awards the Hmong, the heroic but smaller ethnic group of allies who lived in northeast Laos within Military Region 2 the Gold Medal. (see maps 2 & 4) The bills language attributes the Hmong as interrupting the Ho Chi Minh Supply Trail (see maps 1, 1A, 1B). Unfortunately this is totally incorrect. The Hmong, the Lowland Lao and Lao Theung in Military Region 2 did interrupt North Vietnamese convoys along Old Colonial Route 7, which could never be mistaken or considered a part of the vast Ho Chi Minh Trail network in southern Laos. The Hmong, those Lao Theung and the Lowland Lao in Military Region 2,  were often supported by the Lowland Lao and Lao Theung from Military Regions 1, 3, & 4.  They regularly reinforced the Hmong and defended The Plain of Jars in Military Region 2.  With CIA direction and support from the Thai PARU, the vitally important TACAN and Lima Sites were reinforced and defended when needed. (see, https://www.cavwv.org/lao-lima-sites.html). 
​
“According to CIA historian Thomas  Ahern Jr. and Air America scholar William  Leary, the irregular campaign in Laos drew upon the full spectrum of the country’s people — ethnic Lao, Lao Theung, and Hmong, together with other Lao Sung communities such as the Lu Mien and Khmu. CIA Station Chief Hugh Tovar later emphasized that the Lao Sung and Lao Theung Special Guerilla Units formed the backbone of sustained combat operations, fielding larger numbers of soldiers, suffering heavier losses, and proving decisive in the central and southern theaters (Military Regions 3 and 4). These same units, reinforced by Thai Volunteer Special Guerilla Units, were also major contributors to the defense of Skyline Ridge in early 1972, a battle whose success owed much to the redeployment of southern Lao irregulars under CIA direction—an action for which Military Region 3 Special Guerilla Units and CIA case officer Eli Chavez received the Intelligence Star.  While Hmong forces in Military Region 2 received greater public attention after the war, the broader multi-ethnic Special Guerilla Units structure—supported logistically by Air America’s airlift network and coordinated through CIA Headquarters (Far East Division) at the Vientiane Station—was the true foundation of the U.S. irregular campaign in Laos.”

Source: CIA History Staff (Thomas L. Ahern Jr., Undercover Armies)
https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB284/6-UNDERCOVER_ARMIES.pdf
William M. Leary (CIA Air Operations in Laos, 1955–1974)
https://www.cia.gov/resources/csi/studies-in-intelligence/studies-in-intelligence-winter-1999-2000/cia-air-operations-in-laos-1955-1974/, and James E. Parker (Battle for Skyline Ridge). Also see the oral history of Hugh B. Tovar, CIA Station Chief Vientiane (1968–1973).

According to CIA station chief in Laos, Hugh Tovar (1970-1972) , "the Hmong didn't fight in the Ho Chi Minh Trail..."(Baird and Hillmer 2020), This fact is suported by CIA Chief of Station Richard Holm (1961-1962) (C-span event 1996), Colonel Khao Insixiengmay, (Guerilla Mobile 30) (History of the War in Laos) and Colonel Khambang Sibounheuang, (Guerila Mobile 31)(White Dragon 2) both Lowland Lao Royal Lao Armed Forces Officers and Special Guerilla Units commanders in Military Region 3.  Additionally,  many United States MACV SOG teams who were led by Americans such as John Meyer (Across the Fence) , Kenneth Bowra (The NVA and Viet Cong- The War in Cambodia 1970-75), Tim Kirk and Gamble Dick (A Glorious Nightmare) led Ethnic Nung and Khmer in Laos and Cambodia along the trail.  Khmer Kim Son Chau, Sarinh Chau and Villa Chau were commandos who clandestinely operated in Laos and Cambodia under MACV SOG and CIA direction. Vietnamese Commandos Tran Van Quy and Thien Hoang who were trained and directed by the CIA (OPLAN 34A, Strategic Technical Directorate Naval Advisory Detachment) also performed Road Watch and North Vietnam operations in and from Laos.  CIA case officers Thomas Briggs (1970-72) (Military Region 4, Pakse) and Eli Chevez (1970-73) (Military Region 3, Savannakhet) directed Lowland Lao in Laos.  The Hmong seldom if ever ventured out of Military Region 2 except for those who trained in Thailand and the United States. In fact the Ho Chi Minh Trail  enters Laos much farther south of Military Region 2, southwest of  Vinh in North Vietnam. The Ho Chi Minh Trail enters Laos through the Nape, Mu Gia, Ban Karai and Ban Raving passes mid Military Region 3 and then extends south into Military Region 4 in southern Laos, and into Cambodia, its arteries piercing into South Vietnam along the way. (see maps 1, 1a & 1b)

​ https://www.c-span.org/clip/public-affairs-event/user-clip-road-watch-operation-and-the-ho-chi-minh-trail/5160439 

        The Ho Chi Minh Trail was in fact interrupted by the Lowland Lao in Military Regions 3 & 4, by the indigenous Free Khmer from Cambodia, the Free ethnic Chinese Nung and by the indigenous tribes of the Montagnards along the Annamite Mountains in South Vietnam and by the South Vietnamese in I Corps, II Corps and III Corps in South Vietnam. 

A lesser known fact is that the Sihanouk Trail in Cambodia was another vital supply line used by the North Vietnamese in direct violation of Cambodia's declared neutrality after the signing of the Geneva Accords in 1954. (see map 1). Much of North Vietnams weapons caches and sanctuaries were located in Cambodia along the boarder of Cambodia and South Vietnam, easily accessable by both North Vietnamese and Viet Cong Guerrillas. ( see map 6)

       The bill's language is an unfortunate error and has disappointed those veterans who actually did interrupt supplies and munitions of the Communist Vietnamese along the Ho Chi Minh and Sihanouk Trails.

       Many believe this omission must be corrected and these allies must be  nominated and awarded a Gold Medal as the Hmong have for their service.  A well deserved honor, to whom these brave allies are equally deserving.

       The Chief sponsors have been made aware of the error and our Allies are awaiting a remedy or correction. No response or comment has been received from Senator Kloburchar, Senator Peters or Representative Glenn Grothman to date.  No comment has been received from any of the bills cosponsors either.
Map 4, Military Regions in Laos
​Map 5. A CIA image of Laos illustrating the different military regions (MR) with an enlargement of MR II where the ground war involving the “secret army” under General Vang Pao’s command operated. Several important landmarks for the ground war and key features in Hmong refugee stories are indicated in the enlargement, including Long Cheng (the “secret” military base), Sam Thong, Pa Dong, and the Plain of Jars. Source: Thomas L. Ahern, Undercover Armies: CIA and Surrogate Warfare in Laos, 1961-1973 (Center for the Study of Intelligence, 2006). Source: FOIA, accessed October 1, 2010. (C05303949) http://www.gwu.edu/~nsarchiv/NSAEBB/NSAEBB284/index.htm.
Map 2A - Northern Laos, Spot indicates Plain of Jars in Military Region 2
Map 7 - Road capacity map of Laos indicating Old Colonial Route 7 entering MR2 at upper left corner of map.
Map 1A - Ho Chi Minh and Sihanouk Trail networks in Cambodia an Sothern Laos with trail heads and entry points.
Map 6, NVA weapons cashes in Cambodia
Map 1 - Greater Supply route map of Vietnam, Laos & Cambodia 
Map 1B - Route Network of the Ho Chi Minh Trail in Military 3 & 4, Laos
For more information about the Ho Chi Minh Trail, the Hmong and the Secret War in Laos, please visit: https://www.cavwv.org/laos-the-secret-war.html
To learn more about the equally controversial Hmong Burial Bill. visit: ​ https://cavwv.org/hmong-burial-contoversy.html
Veterans from Laos: War, Remembrance, Ritual, Rank, Racism, and the Making of Hmong and Lao America by Ian Baird and Paul Hillmer, Hmong Studies Journal, 21(2020): 1-37.
C-Span April 20, 1996, Washington DC panel discussion on " U.S Intelligence Activity in Laos. "
" Should not all our Allies receive equal recognition for defending democracy and demonstrating loyalty and brotherhood to our common mission and cause?  We certainly do."

Bill Sponsors

United States Senate - S 3271

     Ron Johnson [R-WI]* 11/09/2023; Baldwin, Tammy [D-WI]*11/09/2023;
     Tillis, Thomas [R-NC]*11/09/2023;; Klobuchar, Amy [D-MN]*11/09/2023
     Stabenow, Debbie [D-MI]*11/27/2023; Whitehouse, Sheldon [D-RI]*
     12/19/2023; Tester, Jon [D-MT]* 01/08/2024; Gary Peters, [D-M]I*11/09/23

Controversy -
Erroneous sighted facts
and errors 
  House of Representatives - HR 2437
​
​      John S. Duarte (CA); Ryan K. Zinke (MT); Doug LaMalfa (CA); Mike Johnson (LA);
       Andy Harris (MD); Richard Hudson (NC); Jack Bergman (MI); James R. Baird (IN);
       Harriet M. Hageman (WY); James Comer (KY); John R. Carter (TX); Dusty Johnson
       (SD); Alexander X. Mooney (WV); Kay Granger (TX); J. French Hill (AR); Claudia
       Tenney (NY); Gwen Moore (WI); Mike Gallagher (WI); Clay Higgins (LA); Thomas P.
       Tiffany (WI); Bryan Steil (WI); Scott Fitzgerald (WI); Ken Buck (CO); Don Bacon (NE);
       Carol D. Miller (WV); Debbie Lesko (AZ); Troy E. Nehls (TX); J. Luis Correa (CA);
        Norma J. Torres (CA); Juan Vargas (CA); Wesley Hunt (TX); Julia Brownley (CA);
        Pat Fallon (TX); Bruce Westerman (AR); Mark Pocan (WI); Guy Reschenthaler (PA);
        Mike Bost (IL); David G. Valadao (CA); Glenn Thompson (PA); Russell Fry (SC);
        Brian K. Fitzpatrick (PA); Doug Lamborn (CO); Kevin Kiley (CA); Jim Costa (CA);
        Katie Porter (CA); Michelle Steel (CA); Burgess Owens (UT)
(see Ho Chi Minh Trail)

The Coalition of Allied Vietnam War Veterans is a former 501(c)3 non profit which ceased operating under that IRS status at the end of 2025 which was the 50th anniversary year of the ending of the Vietnam War.
It now operates as a Veteran Fellowship located in the State of Minnesota